://osf.io/6d5nq
osf:PreprintInvestigating Issues with Reproducibility in Journal Articles Published in Psychological Science
https://osf.io/6d5nq
more details...
- dcterms:created
language:en Date created
language:en Date Created
2023-08-02
- dcterms:dateAccepted
language:en Date accepted
language:en Date Accepted
2024-06-20
- dcterms:dateCopyrighted
language:en Date copyrighted
language:en Date Copyrighted
2023
- dcterms:dateSubmitted
language:en Date Submitted
language:en Date submitted
2023-08-02
- dcterms:description
language:en Description
Amidst growing concern over the reproducibility of psychological research (Open Science Collaboration, 2015; Baker, 2016), efforts have been made by academic journals to incentivise open science practises (OSPs) that help to defend the integrity of psychological research from the fallout of the “replication crisis” (Shrout & Rodgers, 2018). Psychological Science implemented their “Open practises badge” policy in 2014 (Eich, 2014) to award authors who adhere to 3 OSPs: preregistration, open data and open materials. However, such a policy has been criticised for substantially failing to achieve its goals (Nuijten et al., 2017; Hardwicke et al., 2021; Crüwell et al., 2022). The present investigation aims to highlight issues with reproducibility in articles published in Psychological Science by attempting the reproduction of a total of 80 analyses, tables and figures from 3 articles published in the journal in 2022/23. This investigation found only 40 (50%) of these were reproducible “entirely” and results highlighted a number of important issues that hinder reproducibility. Potential solutions to enhance reproducibility in psychological research are discussed. Supplementary materials can be found in the following OSF repository (https://osf.io/yw3cs/view_only=1c7e5cc286484eb7978784ffc345dd54)
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/6d5nq
https://osf.io/6d5nq
- dcterms:modified
language:en Date Modified
language:en Date modified
2024-08-01
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
Investigating Issues with Reproducibility in Journal Articles Published in Psychological Science
- osf:keyword
language:en Tag
metascience
open science practices
psychological science
reproducibility
- osf:storageByteCount
xsd:integer 30546990
- dcterms:creator
language:en Creator
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Person://osf.io/buhnd
Charlie Homewood
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io/buhnd
http://github.com/CharlieHomewood
https://www.linkedin.com/in/charliehomewood/
- foaf:name
name
language:en Name
Charlie Homewood
- dcterms:identifier
- dcterms:publisher
language:en Provider
language:en Publisher
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Organization://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv
PsyArXiv
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv
https://psyarxiv.com/
- foaf:name
language:en Name
name
PsyArXiv
- dcterms:identifier
- dcterms:rights
language:en License
language:en Rights
://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode
CC-By Attribution 4.0 International
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode
- foaf:name
name
language:en Name
CC-By Attribution 4.0 International
- dcterms:identifier
- dcterms:subject
language:en Subject
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecab4e
Quantitative Psychology
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Quantitative Psychology
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68
Psychology
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Psychology
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac48
Social and Behavioral Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Social and Behavioral Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac48
Social and Behavioral Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Social and Behavioral Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/59baec7354be810242f552fa
Research Methods in Life Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Research Methods in Life Sciences
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecaab0
Life Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Life Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7426c6983001430b6c45
Psychology, other
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Psychology, other
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac48
Social and Behavioral Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Social and Behavioral Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://api.osf.io/v2/providers/preprints/psyarxiv/subjects/
PsyArXiv
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
PsyArXiv
- dcterms:title
- skos:related
language:en has related
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68
Psychology
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Psychology
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac48
Social and Behavioral Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Social and Behavioral Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68
Psychology
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Psychology
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac48
Social and Behavioral Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Social and Behavioral Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7424c6983001430b6c19
Meta-science
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Meta-science
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://api.osf.io/v2/providers/preprints/psyarxiv/subjects/
PsyArXiv
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
PsyArXiv
- dcterms:title
- skos:related
language:en has related
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/59baec7354be810242f552fa
Research Methods in Life Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Research Methods in Life Sciences
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecaab0
Life Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Life Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecaab0
Life Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Life Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7426c6983001430b6c41
Quantitative Methods
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Quantitative Methods
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac48
Social and Behavioral Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Social and Behavioral Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://api.osf.io/v2/providers/preprints/psyarxiv/subjects/
PsyArXiv
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
PsyArXiv
- dcterms:title
- skos:related
language:en has related
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecab4e
Quantitative Psychology
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Quantitative Psychology
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68
Psychology
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Psychology
- skos:broader
language:en has broader
skos:Concept://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac48
Social and Behavioral Sciences
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
Social and Behavioral Sciences
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:inScheme
language:en is in scheme
skos:ConceptScheme://bepress.com/reference_guide_dc/disciplines/
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
more details...
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
bepress Digital Commons Three-Tiered Taxonomy
- dcterms:title
- skos:prefLabel
- skos:prefLabel
- dcterms:type
language:en Resource type
language:en Type
datacite:Preprint
language:en Preprint
more details...
- rdfs:label
label
language:en Label
language:en Preprint
- rdfs:label
- owl:sameAs
sameAs
://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/6d5nq - dcat:accessService
language:da dataadgangstjeneste
language:es servicio de acceso de datos
language:en data access service
language:cs služba pro přístup k datům
language:it servizio di accesso ai dati
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Organization://osf.io
OSF
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io
- foaf:name
language:en Name
name
OSF
- dcterms:identifier
- osf:hasDataResource
language:en Data
://osf.io/yw3cs/?view_only=1c7e5cc286484eb7978784ffc345dd54 - osf:hostingInstitution
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Organization://cos.io/
Center for Open Science
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://ror.org/05d5mza29
https://cos.io/
- foaf:name
language:en Name
name
Center for Open Science
- owl:sameAs
sameAs
://ror.org/05d5mza29
- dcterms:identifier
- osf:isSupplementedBy
language:en Supplemental materials
osf:Project://osf.io/yw3cs
Investigating Issues with Reproducibility in Journal Articles Published in Psychological Science
more details...
- dcterms:created
language:en Date created
language:en Date Created
2023-04-27
- dcterms:dateCopyrighted
language:en Date Copyrighted
language:en Date copyrighted
2023
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io/yw3cs
- dcterms:title
language:en Title
Investigating Issues with Reproducibility in Journal Articles Published in Psychological Science
- dcterms:creator
language:en Creator
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Person://osf.io/buhnd
Charlie Homewood
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io/buhnd
http://github.com/CharlieHomewood
https://www.linkedin.com/in/charliehomewood/
- foaf:name
language:en Name
name
Charlie Homewood
- dcterms:identifier
- dcterms:publisher
language:en Publisher
language:en Provider
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Organization://osf.io
OSF
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io
- foaf:name
name
language:en Name
OSF
- dcterms:identifier
- dcterms:rights
language:en License
language:en Rights
://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode
CC-By Attribution 4.0 International
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode
- foaf:name
name
language:en Name
CC-By Attribution 4.0 International
- dcterms:identifier
- dcterms:created
- osf:statedConflictOfInterest
language:en Stated conflict of interest
osf:no-conflict-of-interest language:en Creator asserts no conflict of interest.
- osf:storageRegion
://api.osf.io/v2/regions/us/
language:en United States
more details...
- skos:prefLabel
language:en preferred label
language:en United States
- skos:prefLabel
- foaf:isPrimaryTopicOf
is primary topic of
/trove/index-card/3e15dada-d78b-4636-8199-4342789f8ab1 - prov:qualifiedAttribution
qualifiedAttribution
- prov:agent
agent
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Person://osf.io/buhnd
Charlie Homewood
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io/buhnd
http://github.com/CharlieHomewood
https://www.linkedin.com/in/charliehomewood/
- foaf:name
name
language:en Name
Charlie Homewood
- dcterms:identifier
- dcat:hadRole
language:da havde rolle
language:en hadRole
language:it tiene rol
language:cs sehraná role
language:it haRuolo
osf:admin-contributor
- prov:agent
- osf:usage
- osf:downloadSessionCount
xsd:integer 87
- osf:viewSessionCount
xsd:integer 5
- osf:viewCount
xsd:integer 5
- dcterms:temporal
language:en Temporal Coverage
xsd:gYearMonth 2026-09
- osf:downloadCount
xsd:integer 87
- dcat:accessService
language:cs služba pro přístup k datům
language:en data access service
language:da dataadgangstjeneste
language:es servicio de acceso de datos
language:it servizio di accesso ai dati
dcterms:Agentfoaf:Organization://osf.io
OSF
more details...
- dcterms:identifier
language:en Identifier
https://osf.io
- foaf:name
language:en Name
name
OSF
- dcterms:identifier
- foaf:primaryTopic
primary topic
://osf.io/6d5nq Investigating Issues with Reproducibility in Journal Articles Published in Psychological Science