://osf.io/qup53

osf:Preprint
The effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviour: A review and meta- analysis
https://osf.io/qup53
more details...
dcterms:created
2023-01-13
dcterms:dateAccepted
2024-06-20
dcterms:dateCopyrighted
2023
dcterms:dateSubmitted
2023-01-13
dcterms:description
Research from the social sciences suggests an association between higher temperatures and increases in antisocial behaviours, including aggressive, violent, or sabotaging behaviours, and represents a heat-facilitates-aggression perspective. More recently, studies have shown that higher temperature experiences may also be linked to increases in prosocial behaviours, such as altruistic, sharing, or cooperative behaviours, representing a warmth-primes-prosociality view. However, across both literatures, there have been inconsistent findings and failures to replicate key theoretical predictions, leaving the status of temperature-behaviour links unclear. Here we review the literature and conduct meta-analyses of available empirical studies that have either prosocial (e.g., monetary reward, gift giving, helping behaviour) or antisocial (self-rewarding, retaliation, sabotaging behaviour) behavioural outcome variables, with temperature as an independent variable. In an omnibus multivariate analysis (total N = 4577) with 80 effect sizes, we found that there was no reliable effect of temperature on the behavioural outcomes measured. Further, we find little support for either the warmth-primes-prosociality view or the heat- facilitates-aggression view. There were no reliable effects if we consider separately the type of behavioural outcome (prosocial or antisocial), different types of temperature experience (haptic or ambient), or potential interactions with the experimental social context (positive, neutral or negative). We discuss how these findings affect the status of existing theoretical perspectives, and provide specific suggestions advancing research in this area.
dcterms:identifier
https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/qup53
https://osf.io/qup53
dcterms:modified
2023-01-16
dcterms:title
The effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviour: A review and meta- analysis
osf:keyword
aggression
antisocial
temperature
prosocial
priming
behaviour
altruism
osf:storageByteCount
dcterms:creator
dcterms:publisher
dcterms:requires

://osf.io/62qju

osf:File
Lynott-etAl-2023-TemperatureMetaAnalysis.BJSP.Preprint.pdf
more details...
dcterms:created
2023-01-13
dcterms:identifier
https://osf.io/62qju
dcterms:modified
2023-01-16
osf:fileName
Lynott-etAl-2023-TemperatureMetaAnalysis.BJSP.Preprint.pdf
osf:filePath
/Lynott-etAl-2023-TemperatureMetaAnalysis.BJSP.Preprint.pdf
osf:hasFileVersion

://osf.io/62qju
?revision=1

osf:FileVersion
more details...
dcterms:created
2023-01-13
dcterms:extent
1.7 MB
dcterms:format
application/octet-stream
dcterms:modified
2023-01-13
osf:versionNumber
1
dcterms:creator
dcterms:requires
osf:storageRegion
osf:isContainedBy
://osf.io/qup53
The effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviour: A review and meta- analysis
dcterms:rights
dcterms:subject

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecaab6

skos:Concept
Social Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Social Psychology
skos:broader

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68

skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7426c6983001430b6c6b

skos:Concept
Prosocial Behavior
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Prosocial Behavior
skos:broader

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7425c6983001430b6c34

skos:Concept
Social and Personality Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Social and Personality Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:related

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240d954be81056cecaa42

skos:Concept
Personality and Social Contexts
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Personality and Social Contexts
skos:broader
://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68
skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme
skos:related

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecaab6

skos:Concept
Social Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Social Psychology
skos:broader

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68

skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7424c6983001430b6c19

skos:Concept
Meta-science
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Meta-science
skos:inScheme
skos:related

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/59baec7354be810242f552fa

skos:Concept
Research Methods in Life Sciences
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Research Methods in Life Sciences
skos:broader
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/59baec7354be810242f552fa

skos:Concept
Research Methods in Life Sciences
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Research Methods in Life Sciences
skos:broader
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240d954be81056cecaa42

skos:Concept
Personality and Social Contexts
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Personality and Social Contexts
skos:broader

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68

skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7426c6983001430b6c45

skos:Concept
Psychology, other
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology, other
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:related

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68

skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7425c6983001430b6c34

skos:Concept
Social and Personality Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Social and Personality Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:related

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240d954be81056cecaa42

skos:Concept
Personality and Social Contexts
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Personality and Social Contexts
skos:broader

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68

skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68

skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7427c6983001430b6c75

skos:Concept
Violence and Aggression
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Violence and Aggression
skos:broader

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/5b4e7425c6983001430b6c34

skos:Concept
Social and Personality Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Social and Personality Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:related

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240d954be81056cecaa42

skos:Concept
Personality and Social Contexts
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Personality and Social Contexts
skos:broader
://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68
skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme
skos:related

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecaab6

skos:Concept
Social Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Social Psychology
skos:broader

://api.osf.io/v2/subjects/584240da54be81056cecac68

skos:Concept
Psychology
more details...
skos:prefLabel
Psychology
skos:broader
skos:inScheme
skos:inScheme
dcterms:type
owl:sameAs
sameAs
dcat:accessService
osf:contains

://osf.io/62qju

osf:File
Lynott-etAl-2023-TemperatureMetaAnalysis.BJSP.Preprint.pdf
more details...
dcterms:created
2023-01-13
dcterms:identifier
https://osf.io/62qju
dcterms:modified
2023-01-16
osf:fileName
Lynott-etAl-2023-TemperatureMetaAnalysis.BJSP.Preprint.pdf
osf:filePath
/Lynott-etAl-2023-TemperatureMetaAnalysis.BJSP.Preprint.pdf
osf:hasFileVersion

://osf.io/62qju
?revision=1

osf:FileVersion
more details...
dcterms:created
2023-01-13
dcterms:extent
1.7 MB
dcterms:format
application/octet-stream
dcterms:modified
2023-01-13
osf:versionNumber
1
dcterms:creator
dcterms:requires
osf:storageRegion
osf:isContainedBy
://osf.io/qup53
The effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviour: A review and meta- analysis
osf:hasDataResource
osf:hostingInstitution
osf:isSupplementedBy

://osf.io/xpyzj

osf:Project
Meta-analysis: Effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviours
more details...
dcterms:created
2018-04-23
dcterms:dateCopyrighted
2020
dcterms:identifier
https://osf.io/xpyzj
dcterms:title
Meta-analysis: Effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviours
dcterms:creator
dcterms:publisher
dcterms:rights
osf:statedConflictOfInterest
osf:storageRegion
foaf:isPrimaryTopicOf
is primary topic of
prov:qualifiedAttribution
qualifiedAttribution
osf:order
prov:agent
agent
dcat:hadRole
osf:order
prov:agent
agent
dcat:hadRole
osf:order
prov:agent
agent
dcat:hadRole
osf:order
dcat:hadRole
prov:agent
agent
osf:omits
dcterms:description
This meta-analysis was not preregistered, but we have shared code and data in order to be as transparent as possible.
osf:omittedMetadataProperty
osf:usage
osf:downloadCount
osf:downloadSessionCount
osf:viewCount
osf:viewSessionCount
dcterms:temporal
foaf:primaryTopic
primary topic
://osf.io/qup53
The effects of temperature on prosocial and antisocial behaviour: A review and meta- analysis
dcat:accessService